Carabin Shaw is one of the leading personal injury law firms in San Antonio and Texas. They have extensive experience in truck/18-wheeler accident cases, focusing on securing compensation for clients that reflects the full extent of their medical bills, property damage, and pain and suffering.
Specialization: Personal injury, truck accidents, car accidents, wrongful death, 18-wheeler accidents.
Why choose them? Carabin Shaw Law Firm offers a complimentary initial consultation, and their team is recognized for aggressively advocating for their clients’ rights.

Why Truck Drivers Lie After Accidents and How Attorneys Expose the Truth

Truck drivers lie after accidents more frequently than most people realize, and their motivations are powerful. Truck drivers lie because a single at-fault accident can end their careers permanently, leaving them unable to support their families. Truck drivers lie because they know trucking companies won’t hire someone with a serious accident on their record, and their current employer will terminate them immediately. When faced with the choice between honesty and unemployment, some drivers choose dishonesty. Understanding why truck drivers lie and how attorneys uncover the truth can mean the difference between winning and losing your injury claim.

href=”https://www.carabinshaw.com/commercial-vehicle-accident-lawyers-in-laredo-texas.html” target=”_blank”>Wrongful Truck / 18 Wheeler accident Lawyers in Laredo Today!

The Career-Ending Stakes That Drive Dishonesty

Commercial truck driving offers stable income for workers without college degrees, with the Bureau of Labor Statistics reporting median annual wages of $49,920 for heavy truck drivers in 2022. Many drivers support entire families on this income. They’ve invested years building their careers, obtaining their commercial driver’s license, and establishing safety records with their employers.

href=”https://www.carabinshaw.com/severe-injury-following-an-18-wheeler-accident-in-laredo.html” target=”_blank”>Wrongful Truck / 18 Wheeler accident Lawyers in Laredo Today!

One at-fault accident threatens everything. Trucking companies scrutinize driver safety records intensely because accidents cost them millions in insurance premiums, legal liability, and damaged reputation. A driver found responsible for a serious crash faces immediate termination in most cases. Other trucking companies won’t hire them either, as background checks reveal their accident history.

This creates enormous incentive to shift blame onto you, the victim. If the driver can convince investigators that you caused the collision by changing lanes unsafely, running a red light, or driving recklessly, they preserve their career and livelihood. They may genuinely convince themselves of this alternative version of events, or they may knowingly fabricate lies. Either way, their false account threatens your ability to recover compensation for your injuries.

Common Lies Truck Drivers Tell After Crashes

Certain false narratives appear repeatedly in trucking accident investigations. Drivers claim you pulled out in front of them suddenly, giving them no time to react. They insist they were traveling at or below the speed limit when evidence shows otherwise. They deny texting or using their phone despite cell phone records proving extensive use at the time of impact.

Drivers fabricate stories about vehicle malfunctions, claiming their brakes failed or steering problems caused the accident. They minimize their role by suggesting you share equal blame for the collision. They deny falling asleep at the wheel even when evidence points to fatigue. Some drivers coordinate their stories with trucking company representatives before speaking with investigators.

The most damaging lies involve falsifying logbooks and hours-of-service records. Federal regulations limit how many hours drivers can operate vehicles without rest breaks, but these rules cut into company profits. Some drivers, pressured by employers or trying to maximize their own earnings, exceed legal driving hours and then alter their logs to hide violations. When accidents occur during these illegal driving periods, drivers have massive incentive to destroy or alter records.

How Experienced Attorneys Expose Driver Dishonesty

Skilled trucking accident attorneys know where to find evidence that contradicts driver lies. Modern commercial trucks contain electronic logging devices that automatically record hours of operation, preventing manual logbook manipulation. These devices capture data that drivers cannot alter, providing an objective record of driving time, rest breaks, and vehicle operation.

Event data recorders, similar to airplane black boxes, store critical information about vehicle speed, brake application, throttle position, and other factors in the seconds before a crash. When drivers claim they were traveling the speed limit, event data often proves they were speeding. When they deny hard braking, the data shows they never touched the brakes at all.

Cell phone records reveal texting, calling, or app usage at the moment of impact, contradicting claims of attentive driving. Surveillance cameras from nearby businesses, traffic cameras, and dashcams from other vehicles capture the collision from multiple angles, making it impossible for drivers to maintain false narratives when video evidence clearly shows their negligence.

Witness statements provide powerful corroboration of your account. Independent third parties have no reason to lie about what they observed. When multiple witnesses describe events identically to your version, and completely contrary to the driver’s claims, the driver’s credibility collapses.

The Power of Depositions in Uncovering Truth

Depositions represent one of the most effective tools for exposing dishonest drivers. During a deposition, attorneys question the driver under oath, with their testimony recorded by a court reporter. Everything the driver says becomes part of the permanent legal record and can be used against them at trial.

Experienced attorneys use sophisticated questioning techniques developed over thousands of depositions. They start with background questions, establishing basic facts the driver cannot dispute. Then they move methodically through the accident sequence, asking detailed questions about timing, distances, speeds, and observations. They return to inconsistencies, asking the same questions in different ways, watching for variations in the driver’s answers.

Many drivers crack under this pressure. They forget details of their fabricated story. They contradict themselves when asked the same question differently. They become defensive or hostile, damaging their credibility. Some eventually admit the truth when confronted with contradictory evidence. Even drivers who maintain their lies throughout the deposition often appear so uncomfortable and evasive that judges and juries see through them.

Insurance Company Tactics Designed to Defeat Your Claim

Federal regulations require commercial trucks to carry minimum insurance coverage of $750,000, with many policies worth several million dollars. These high-value policies mean insurance companies have enormous financial stakes in denying claims. They dedicate significant resources to fighting truck accident cases, employing strategies designed to minimize or eliminate payouts.

Insurance adjusters assigned to truck accident claims differ dramatically from those handling routine fender benders. These are senior-level professionals who earned their positions by saving their companies millions of dollars through claim denials and lowball settlements. They view you as an adversary, not someone deserving help after a traumatic accident.

Their initial approach seems friendly and helpful. They call expressing concern for your wellbeing and asking for your version of events. They frame their questions as routine information gathering, necessary for processing your claim. This friendliness is strategic deception. Their goal is recording statements they can use against you.

They ask leading questions designed to elicit responses suggesting you share fault for the accident. They inquire about pre-existing injuries or prior accidents, looking for reasons to deny your claim or reduce its value. They request authorizations to access all your medical records, searching for ammunition to dispute your injuries. Everything you say gets recorded, transcribed, and analyzed by defense attorneys looking for inconsistencies or admissions.

Why You Should Never Speak With Truck Insurance Adjusters

Politely decline to provide recorded statements to truck insurance adjusters. Texas law does not require you to speak with the at-fault driver’s insurance company. You must cooperate with your own insurance carrier, but you have no obligation to help the trucking company’s insurer build a defense against your claim.

Even seemingly innocent statements can destroy your case. You might mention feeling “fine” the day after the accident, not realizing soft tissue injuries often don’t manifest immediately. The insurance company will seize on this statement, arguing you weren’t seriously injured. You might estimate your speed or describe the collision sequence in ways that subtly differ from the police report. These inconsistencies, no matter how minor, become ammunition for defense attorneys.

Let your attorney handle all communication with insurance companies. They understand the games adjusters play and the traps they set. They provide necessary information without giving adjusters opportunities to twist your words or manufacture defenses.

Defense Attorneys Who Know Every Legal Loophole

Large insurance carriers retain law firms specializing in trucking defense. These attorneys know federal motor carrier safety regulations, state transportation laws, and insurance policy provisions inside and out. They identify technical defenses that can get cases dismissed before trial, such as procedural errors in how you filed your lawsuit or defects in how you served legal papers.

They file motions challenging every aspect of your case, forcing your attorney to respond and defend positions that should be straightforward. They demand extensive discovery, burying your attorney in document requests and interrogatories. They depose every witness multiple times, looking for any variation in testimony. These tactics aim to exhaust you and your attorney, hoping you’ll accept a low settlement rather than continue fighting.

Countering these strategies requires experience and resources. Attorneys who regularly handle truck accident litigation know defense tactics because they’ve seen them hundreds of times before. They anticipate defense moves and prepare responses before defense attorneys even file their motions. They have the financial resources to hire expert witnesses, conduct thorough investigations, and take cases to trial when necessary.

Level the Playing Field With Experienced Representation

Truck drivers and insurance companies have every advantage when you face them alone. They have legal teams, investigators, and unlimited resources. They know the law and how to manipulate it in their favor. They’ve handled thousands of accident claims and know every tactic to minimize or deny compensation.

Hiring an experienced trucking accident attorney levels this playing field. Your attorney matches their resources, matches their experience, and protects you from their tactics. They gather evidence proving the driver’s dishonesty, expose insurance company manipulation, and fight for full compensation covering all your injuries and losses. Don’t let truck drivers’ lies or insurance company games prevent you from receiving the justice you deserve.